Super Stay Teddy Tint Blurred Matte Lip Tint - Maybelline

1/4 4 ways to wear

Just apply and blend.
2/4 4 ways to wear

Dip three times and stay within the lines.
3/4 4 ways to wear

Combine a deeper shade with a lighter shade.
4/4 4 ways to wear

Apply to cheeks and blend for a soft matte
plush look.

Review Highlights

Average rating for this product: 4.2 out of 5 stars

Rating Distribution(539 reviews)

283 reviews with 5 star rating.

135 reviews with 4 star rating.

68 reviews with 3 star rating.

28 reviews with 2 star rating.

25 reviews with 1 star rating.

17 out of 40 (43%) of reviewers would recommend this product to a friend.

Ratings & Reviews

Rating Snapshot

Select a row below to filter reviews.

283 reviews with 5 stars.

134 reviews with 4 stars.

68 reviews with 3 stars.

28 reviews with 2 stars.

25 reviews with 1 star.

Overall Rating

4.2

Review this product

Select to rate the item with 1 star. This action will open submission form.

Select to rate the item with 2 stars. This action will open submission form.

Select to rate the item with 3 stars. This action will open submission form.

Select to rate the item with 4 stars. This action will open submission form.

Select to rate the item with 5 stars. This action will open submission form.

Adding a review will require a valid email for verification

Customer Images and Videos

Review photo 1.

Review photo 2.

Filter Reviews

1 to 8 of 538 Reviews

1 – 8 of 538 Reviews

Lnf7438

Louisiana

Review1

Votes0

Age35 to 44

GenderFemale

3 out of 5 stars.

Color

Lnf7438

5 days ago

I would like to know what color that 1 of your models is wearing

Color?

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Response from maybelline.com:

a day ago

Maybelline

Hi there! We're so glad you love the look! Because lighting, editing, and natural skin undertones can sometimes affect how a shade appears on camera, it can be a bit tricky to identify the exact color a model is wearing without seeing the specific image. If you'd like, you can let us know where you spotted the photo, or you can explore our shade range on our official product page to find a similar look. Our team is always happy to help you find your perfect match!

NZNatty

Wellington, New Zealand

Review1

Votes0

Age35 to 44

GenderFemale

SKIN TONE:Light Medium

EYE COLOR:Blue

HAIR COLOUR:Dark Brown

3 out of 5 stars.

Grunge is a sticky colour

NZNatty

9 days ago

Love the colour (Grunge) but it is VERY sticky and doesn't seem to dry without help from other products, in my case a coat of pawpaw lip balm after a waiting period of 15 or so minutes

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Response from maybelline.com:

9 days ago

Maybelline

Hey! Thank you for sharing your feedback on our Super Stay Teddy Tint Blurred Matte Lip Color. We are so glad you love the Cool Grunge shade, but we are sorry to hear that the formula felt sticky and didn't dry down completely on its own. We appreciate your clever tip about adding a touch of lip balm after waiting for it to set! We’ve passed your comments along to our team for future consideration, and we invite you to explore our other long-wear lip collections to find your next favorite finish. XO

Liplocked611

Oregon

Review1

Votes0

Age35 to 44

GenderFemale

SKIN TONE:Light

EYE COLOR:Blue

HAIR COLOUR:Dark Brown

1 out of 5 stars.

Fell flat as its matte.

Liplocked611

12 days ago

Doesnt stay and its as flat as its matte color. Does not last. And the pigments fall short. No pop. Drying to the lips. Hard pass.

No, I do not recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Response from maybelline.com:

11 days ago

Maybelline

Hey! Thank you for sharing your honest feedback on our Super Stay Teddy Tint. We are so sorry to hear that the formula felt dry and didn't deliver the long-lasting wear or vibrant pigment you were hoping for. We’ve passed your comments regarding the texture and wear directly along to our team for future review. For a more comfortable feel, we suggest applying a thin layer over well-prepped lips, and we also invite you to explore our other long-wear lip collections to find a formula and finish that you truly love! XO

Montréal

Review1

Votes0

Age45 to 54

SKIN TONE:Light

EYE COLOR:Green

HAIR COLOUR:Red/Auburn

1 out of 5 stars.

I do not like it

23 days ago

I bought it yesterday and it hasn’t nearly nothing in the bottle. And the liquid is so thick I can barely have it on the lipstick. I am really disappointed.

No, I do not recommend this product.

Helpful?

Response from Maybelline New York Canada:

17 days ago

BEC

Thank you for sharing your feedback on our Super Stay Teddy Tint™. This lip product provides a soft tint that lasts for up to 12 hours. Available in 12 buildable shades that can be worn on the lips or cheeks. We are sorry to hear that this product did not meet your expectations. We appreciate your feedback and will be sharing it with other members on our team. Thanks again for sharing. We hope that you continue using our products.

valified

new york, ny

Review1

Votes0

Age35 to 44

GenderFemale

SKIN TONE:Light

EYE COLOR:Brown

HAIR COLOUR:Dark Brown

5 out of 5 stars.

PERFECTION! A NEW FAV. SO LONG, MATTE INK :P

valified

a month ago

WOW okay TEDDY TINT I LOVE YOU! so superstay matte ink has had me in a chokehold for almost a year now. I own 12+ shades. But I always wished I could find a way to enjoy the superstay-ness of it without such a bold lip, for the days that I feel like a blurred look. Traditional lipstick and every other longwear lippy has left me dried out and they never lasted long enough. I bought superstay teddy tint kinda by accident, cuz I had a coupon. Wow! so soft! the color lasted all day! and it was comfy and cute. I fear I will be buying many of these! I got the darkest berry color wild at heart and it looked beyond great on me! (my complexion is like Kat Dennings) SOOOO KISSABLE. 6 stars!

Yes, I recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Rachel5678

Review1

Votes0

Age18 to 24

2 out of 5 stars.

A good product just not the color I was expecting.

Rachel5678

a month ago

I got one of these lip tints in the color soft grunge and the color of the packaging was very different from the actual color of the product. It wasn’t a bad color just not the color I was expecting.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Response from maybelline.com:

a month ago

Consumer Care Center

Hey! Thank you for sharing your thoughts on our Super Stay Teddy Tint. We are so glad to hear that you liked the color, but we are sorry to hear that the packaging did not match the shade inside. We have passed your comments regarding the packaging along to our team for future review. We invite you to explore our other available shades to find your perfect match, and we hope you continue to enjoy that comfortable, blurred matte finish! XO

Skylar2020

Review1

Votes0

Age65 or over

4 out of 5 stars.

Doesn’t last eating greasy food

Skylar2020

2 months ago

I’ve used 24 hour lipstick for used and later the matte finish. I swim for an hour wearing my 👄 with no problem. After washing my face in the shower some color does come off. I have only one criticism: color comes off when eating greasy food like 🍕 or 🍔. Be prepared to reapply.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

FarmerBrwnsdtr26

Review1

Votes0

Age45 to 54

5 out of 5 stars.

Loving the SuperStay Teddy Tints!

FarmerBrwnsdtr26

2 months ago

Found Superstay from influencer "UnBrandied" and am so glad I did. I am in love with all of her suggestions. My favorite is Superstay Teddy Tints (endgame is a fave).

Originally posted on maybelline.com

1 – 8 of 538 Reviews

Next Reviews

No questions have been asked about this product.

Questions

No questions have been asked about this product.