Review Highlights

Average rating for this product: 4.2 out of 5 stars

Rating Distribution(477 reviews)

270 reviews with 5 star rating.

119 reviews with 4 star rating.

39 reviews with 3 star rating.

26 reviews with 2 star rating.

23 reviews with 1 star rating.

59 out of 76 (78%) of reviewers would recommend this product to a friend.

Ratings & Reviews

Rating Snapshot

Select a row below to filter reviews.

261 reviews with 5 stars.

118 reviews with 4 stars.

38 reviews with 3 stars.

26 reviews with 2 stars.

22 reviews with 1 star.

Overall Rating

4.2

Review this product

Select to rate the item with 1 star. This action will open submission form.

Select to rate the item with 2 stars. This action will open submission form.

Select to rate the item with 3 stars. This action will open submission form.

Select to rate the item with 4 stars. This action will open submission form.

Select to rate the item with 5 stars. This action will open submission form.

Adding a review will require a valid email for verification

Customer Images and Videos

Filter Reviews

1 to 8 of 465 Reviews

1 – 8 of 465 Reviews

BMcK75

Abington, PA

Review1

Votes0

Age65 or over

GenderFemale

SKIN TONE:Light Medium

EYE COLOR:Brown

HAIR COLOUR:Grey

5 out of 5 stars.

So disappointed

BMcK75

5 months ago

PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE bring back 950 UNTAINTED SPICE CREAM lipstick. Why discontinue such a great color? I get so many complements when I wear it. I'm down to my last tube. Bring it back!! Please!!

Yes, I recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

HoneyBearKelly

Pittsburgh, PA

Review1

Votes0

Age35 to 44

GenderFemale

SKIN TONE:Light

EYE COLOR:Blue

HAIR COLOUR:Medium Brown

5 out of 5 stars.

Great Lipstick

HoneyBearKelly

5 months ago

I love this lipstick! It goes on smooth and doesn't dry out my lips like other lipsticks do

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Montez

Review1

Votes0

Age45 to 54

GenderFemale

SKIN TONE:Medium

EYE COLOR:Brown

HAIR COLOUR:Medium Brown

1 out of 5 stars.

Disappointed

Montez

11 months ago

I am so disappointed that Tainted Spice is no longer an option. Used it for years and had searched everywhere. What the heck!!!!!!!

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Lea20

Dominican Republic

Review1

Votes0

Age18 to 24

GenderFemale

SKIN TONE:Light

EYE COLOR:Brown

HAIR COLOUR:Light Brown

5 out of 5 stars.

The bestiario lipstick

Lea20

a year ago

I simply love it, I have been using it since 2021 and I always choose it for any occasion.

Yes, I recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Calgary, AB

Review1

Votes0

Age45 to 54

SKIN TONE:Medium

EYE COLOR:Brown

HAIR COLOUR:Medium Brown

4 out of 5 stars.

Truffle tease please!!!

a year ago

I miss Truffle Tease 930 too. I find nude lust has too much white and not enough pink and brown so when I put it on, I always have to mix it with other colours and I never get the correct neutral shade which takes too long and then is too heavy on.

Yes, I recommend this product.

Helpful?

Virology

Review1

Votes0

Age55 to 64

5 out of 5 stars.

Best lipstick I've ever bought!.

Virology

a year ago

I LOVE THIS LIPSTICK!!!!! It is sooooooo CREAMY and non DRYING!!!! BEST COLOR FOR MY SKIN TONE.

Yes, I recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

THT84

Review1

Votes0

Age55 to 64

5 out of 5 stars.

Nude Lust & Romantic Rose-Best Shades Ever!!

THT84

a year ago

Love this lipstick. My two favorite shades are "Romantic Rose" and "Nude Lust". I buy multiples of these two shades any time I repurchase. Please do not discontinue these two shades. This lipstick has no odd smell, gives just the right amount of moisture and is very complimentary for us mature ladies. This lipstick wears very well and out performs some of the higher end lipsticks I have tried before.

Yes, I recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Melanie Kay

Columbus GA

Review1

Votes0

Age45 to 54

GenderFemale

SKIN TONE:Light

EYE COLOR:Blue

HAIR COLOUR:Light Brown

5 out of 5 stars.

Plum Perfect is Perfect!

Melanie Kay

a year ago

I love the 435 Plum Perfect!!! To my dismay, I’ve been searching everywhere and it appears to have been discontinued!!! Nooooo!!!! Please don’t do this!!!!! I need to buy your stock call me!!!!! Email me please!!!!!it’s my favorite!!!!!

Yes, I recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

1 – 8 of 465 Reviews

Next Reviews

Ratings & Reviews

Rating Snapshot

Select a row below to filter reviews.

261 reviews with 5 stars.

118 reviews with 4 stars.

38 reviews with 3 stars.

26 reviews with 2 stars.

22 reviews with 1 star.

Overall Rating

4.2

Review this product

Select to rate the item with 1 star. This action will open submission form.

Select to rate the item with 2 stars. This action will open submission form.

Select to rate the item with 3 stars. This action will open submission form.

Select to rate the item with 4 stars. This action will open submission form.

Select to rate the item with 5 stars. This action will open submission form.

Adding a review will require a valid email for verification

Customer Images and Videos

Filter Reviews

9 to 38 of 465 Reviews

9 – 38 of 465 Reviews

MCon

Review1

Votes0

Age45 to 54

5 out of 5 stars.

Please don’t!!

MCon

a year ago

I love the 435 Plum Perfect shade, are you retiring it?? I can’t find it anywhere I used to buy it at

Yes, I recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Anonymous

Oregon

Review1

Votes0

Age45 to 54

GenderFemale

SKIN TONE:Light Medium

EYE COLOR:Green

HAIR COLOUR:Blonde

5 out of 5 stars.

Hooray!

Anonymous

2 years ago

Hooray! Lipstick is fun again! I've been a loyal Revlon lipstick wearer for over 20 years. Recently, it just hasn't been working for my "mature skin". Flaky, cakey, unflattering colors and finishes. Enter... Maybelline Creme Lipstick. Truly creamy. Long lasting. Flattering colors. Lovely finish. My lips don't look old and dry when I wear Maybelline Creme, they look full and nice again. Love it!

Yes, I recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Gracie13

Review1

Votes0

Age18 to 24

2 out of 5 stars.

Color looks pink!

Gracie13

2 years ago

Although i like the formula of the lipsticks the colors seem… off. I bought Crimson Race 311 thinking it would be a pretty dark red color. It even looked red in the tube, but when i applied it it was pink and so much lighter than the color of the product in the tube. I tried applying more product, letting it dry fully, and even a black lip liner underneath but it still looked pink! I don’t know if it’s just my skin tone or if its the actual product but i am not a fan of how different it looks.

No, I do not recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Response from maybelline.com:

2 years ago

Consumer Care Center

Hello there! Thank you for providing us with your feedback regarding our Color Sensational® The Creams in the shade Crimson Race. Based on the information you have provided, we would love to speak to you more about this matter. You can contact us at 800-944-0730. We kindly ask that once you are connected with an agent, please provide them with the reference number located below. We look forward to speaking with you soon. 31371359

Elle780

Florida

Review1

Votes0

Age65 or over

SKIN TONE:Medium

HAIR COLOUR:White

GenderFemale

4 out of 5 stars.

Wonderful but discontinued!

Elle780

2 years ago

Truffle Tease #930 has been discontinued and I write this review in the hopes there is enough outcry that you'll reconsider this move and bring it back. Smooth, great color, no fragrance...perfect.

Yes, I recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Original LadyDi

Georgia

Review1

Votes0

Age55 to 64

SKIN TONE:Light Medium

EYE COLOR:Green

HAIR COLOUR:Light Brown

GenderFemale

3 out of 5 stars.

Color has Changed!

Original LadyDi

2 years ago

I have been wearing Warm Me Up 235 for years. I just bought a replacement and the color is not the same at all. A lot darker and less natural. I’m having to blot most of it off! What happened??

No, I do not recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Response from maybelline.com:

2 years ago

Consumer Care Center

We are so sorry that you were not a fan of the shade Warm Me Up (235) in our Color Sensational The Creams, Cream Finish Lipstick. We suggest trying a lighter shade since you prefer a more natural look. We recommend trying our Color Sensational The Creams, Cream Finish Lipstick in the shade (015) Born With It. To check out this product, please click here: https://tinyurl.com/mssfvka3. Please let us know how you like it! We would love your feedback.

Grams4

Bham Al

Review1

Votes0

Age65 or over

EYE COLOR:Brown

HAIR COLOUR:Light Brown

4 out of 5 stars.

Great

Grams4

3 years ago

I have been searching for #200 Rose Embrace for a while and cannot find it. I purchased 2 of them because they were hard to find. Now I cannot find them at all. Plase bring back that color or tell me where I can find it.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

VJ crafter

Florida

Review1

Votes0

Age55 to 64

SKIN TONE:Medium

EYE COLOR:Brown

HAIR COLOUR:Black

GenderFemale

5 out of 5 stars.

Sugar Bronze

VJ crafter

3 years ago

Please bring back Sugar Bronze. I love ❤️ love love the color. I have been looking for it for years. Maybelline is the the absolute best make up ever.

Yes, I recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Lipstick84

Douglas, GA

Review1

Votes0

Age45 to 54

SKIN TONE:Light Medium

EYE COLOR:Green

HAIR COLOUR:Light Brown

GenderFemale

5 out of 5 stars.

My Favorite Lipstick!!

Lipstick84

3 years ago

My color is Nude Lust (920). I just purchased two more tubes today and have high hopes that Maybelline will not discontinue this shade. This particular formula has always been a winner for me. I'm over 50 and have been wearing this shade since I was in my 30's. It is not drying, but it also is not so creamy that it runs all over the place...and if your over 40 you will appreciate that. I own a lot of lipsticks, but have never repurchased any of them. Long Live Nude Lust!!

Yes, I recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

chelchel

New york, NY

Review1

Votes0

Age25 to 34

5 out of 5 stars.

BRING BACK RUM RICHE :(

chelchel

3 years ago

I love this formula but especially love the shade Rum Riche. I hope they bring it back !

Yes, I recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Cebo

Ohio

Review1

Votes0

Age25 to 34

SKIN TONE:Light

EYE COLOR:Blue

HAIR COLOUR:Dark Brown

GenderFemale

4 out of 5 stars.

Truffle Tease is my signature lipstick

Cebo

3 years ago

Love the formula for The Creams, long-lasting for a creamy formula, very comfortable, and easy to layer/touch up. Maybelline is my favorite drugstore lipstick (favorite lipstick in general), and Truffle Tease is has been my go-to for years. I have had a really hard time finding it in stores lately. Please tell me it's not being discontinued?! I already went through this with Totally Toffee, and I know of several other favorites of others that have also been discontinued. It's incredibly frustrating to have a brand constantly discontinuing products with no warning. Hoping to receive an answer since I can't find any information on this

Yes, I recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Tigerlaf

Review1

Votes0

Age35 to 44

SKIN TONE:Light Medium

EYE COLOR:Hazel

HAIR COLOUR:Light Brown

GenderFemale

5 out of 5 stars.

The best nude red ever

Tigerlaf

3 years ago

If nude red is even a thing, then Rum Riche is the red made right, or the daytime red lipstick. It's a perfect mix of brick red warmth with a hint of plummy coolness, making this shade a perfect not so nude lip. If paired with a brick brown lip pencil this shade becomes a longer lasting evening lip wear for me. I've repurchased this lipstick numerous times. I hope they add this color to their lip vinyl line. Excellent product.

Yes, I recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Coop321

Central NY

Review1

Votes0

Age45 to 54

SKIN TONE:Light Medium

EYE COLOR:Hazel

HAIR COLOUR:Blonde

GenderFemale

5 out of 5 stars.

910 Bare All

Coop321

3 years ago

This was hands down the best lipstick with a cream finish I have found. The color was perfect. I am at a loss that it has been discontinued. Please consider brining it back.

Yes, I recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Reshmavarun

Kerala, india

Review1

Votes0

Age25 to 34

SKIN TONE:Light

EYE COLOR:Brown

HAIR COLOUR:Dark Brown

GenderFemale

5 out of 5 stars.

Alternative to firecracker red

Reshmavarun

3 years ago

Hey, I loved Firecracker red but couldn’t find it anywhere. Is it discontinued? Is there any other replacement shade?

Yes, I recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Patfzdec

Bogota

Review1

Votes0

Age25 to 34

SKIN TONE:Light Medium

EYE COLOR:Hazel

HAIR COLOUR:Dark Brown

GenderFemale

1 out of 5 stars.

Sooo sad I can’t find sin a mon 935 anymore!

Patfzdec

4 years ago

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Where can I find it? Any replacements color? Any dupe?

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Response from maybelline.com:

3 years ago

Consumer Care Center

Hey There! Thank you for reaching out. Unfortunately our Color Sensational® The Creams, Cream Finish Lipstick in the shade 935 Sin-a-mon has been discontinued. We understand how frustrating it is when your go to product is no longer being sold. We suggest trying the shade 205 Nearly There. While this is not an exact replacement, it is in the same color family. We hope you give it a try and love it! XOXO

Lisa11111

Review1

Votes0

Age55 to 64

5 out of 5 stars.

I love this color

Lisa11111

4 years ago

I love the brown blush color. I do not see it. Is it discontinued?

Yes, I recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

kk2022

Review1

Votes0

Age35 to 44

SKIN TONE:Light

EYE COLOR:Blue

HAIR COLOUR:Dark Brown

GenderFemale

1 out of 5 stars.

Rosey Risk

kk2022

4 years ago

the color is more grey than rose and not flattering at all. Lipstick smells like wax and chemicals. Doesn't feel hydrating and has an odd consistency. Will be returning.

No, I do not recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Response from maybelline.com:

4 years ago

Consumer Care Center

Hey kk2022! Thanks for reaching out to us about our Color Sensational® The Creams, Cream Finish Lipstick Makeup. We are so sorry for your experience with it. As consumers ourselves we understand how frustrating it is when a product has an odd smell and consistency. We will be passing your comments along to the rest of our team as we are always looking for ways to improve our products.

sats1

Review1

Votes0

Age65 or over

SKIN TONE:Light

EYE COLOR:Blue

GenderFemale

3 out of 5 stars.

Pretty shade strong fragrance

sats1

4 years ago

I very much like the shades of Maybelline Lipstick especially the pale nudes. I just wish that there was less fragrance in the lipsticks. Please consider reducing it or taking it out at least in some shades. Thanks.

No, I do not recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Response from maybelline.com:

4 years ago

Consumer Care Center

Hi sats1! Thank you for sharing your experience with our Color Sensational® The Creams. We are so happy to hear that you love the pale nude shades! We will be passing your request regarding the fragrance along to our team. We appreciate your honesty and are extremely grateful for your support! XOXO

Dana010

Doha.Qatar

Review1

Votes0

Age25 to 34

SKIN TONE:Light

EYE COLOR:Brown

HAIR COLOUR:Light Brown

GenderFemale

4 out of 5 stars.

Where's 755/Toasted Brown?

Dana010

4 years ago

I bought the shade Toasted Brown #755, but it's not online. I really love this color, and how comfortable is to wear. My only issue is it isn't easy to build up as it gets too buttery/creamy and slides everywhere.

Yes, I recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

CocoMA

Review1

Votes0

Age45 to 54

SKIN TONE:Light Medium

EYE COLOR:Blue

HAIR COLOUR:Blonde

GenderFemale

1 out of 5 stars.

Not a good change

CocoMA

4 years ago

I used to love this lipstick. They changed the formula. It’s not as creamy anymore. Making the bottom bigger and less lipstick is also not a good change

No, I do not recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Response from maybelline.com:

4 years ago

Consumer Care Center

Hi there! Thank you for providing us with this feedback on our Color Sensational Cream Finish Makeup. We are sorry to hear that you are not a fan of our new formula. We will be sure to pass this information you provided us with to the rest of our team. We often times recommend the lips are moisturized before applying any products to them to prevent any dryness when applying. We would like to recommend you check out our Color Sensational Made For All Lipstick. Made This product is our trusted satin and matte formulas with honey nectar for a smooth and comfortable feel. We linked it down below for you to check out! We hope you try it soon and we thank you again for your feedback! https://tinyurl.com/y9os36sv

Lipsss

Review1

Votes0

Age35 to 44

SKIN TONE:Medium

EYE COLOR:Brown

5 out of 5 stars.

Nudes!

Lipsss

5 years ago

Love the nude colors. I had been looking for an older color sin a mon and wonder what has replaced it.

Yes, I recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

GailT

Phoenix

Review1

Votes0

Age18 to 24

SKIN TONE:Light

EYE COLOR:Blue

HAIR COLOUR:Blonde

GenderFemale

5 out of 5 stars.

Best Lipstick Ever

GailT

5 years ago

I bought this lipstick in the "On Fire Red" color. It looked and felt great on me. The creamy feel and smudge proof resistance was 2nd to none. It was easy to apply and made my lips stand out.. Doing the kiss test with my boyfriend, he complimented me on how much he liked how my lips felt on him. Soooo smooth. I need to buy more and try other colors too. Thanks Maybelline.

Yes, I recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

ILoveNYC

New York, NY

Review1

Votes0

Age25 to 34

SKIN TONE:Medium

EYE COLOR:Brown

HAIR COLOUR:Medium Brown

GenderFemale

1 out of 5 stars.

IT WAS DISASTROUS...

ILoveNYC

5 years ago

I bought the 'Red Revolution' color, which was RED. It was a terrible color red. It left a pinkish tone all around my lips after removing. I did not like this one. I would probably purchase them in other colors.

No, I do not recommend this product.

Originally posted on maybelline.com

Response from maybelline.com:

5 years ago

Consumer Care Center

Hey there ILoveNYC! Thank you for reaching out about your experience with our Color Sensational The Creams, Cream Finish Lipstick in the shade Red Revolution. We are sorry to hear that you did not enjoy this shade and that it did not remove well! This lipstick delivers crisp,vibrant lip color and smooth, supple lips. We would be happy to help you pick out a different shade of red. Please do not hesitate to contact us for assistance by calling us at 800-944-0730 (M-F 9:00 am – 5:30 pm ET)!

bethanyc0056

Review1

Votes0

5 out of 5 stars.

bethanyc0056

6 years ago

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I love this lipstick. It has a creamy look and feel to it. And it does last a long time on the lips. Almost like a matte liquid lipstick would look without the dry feeling. The nudes are gorgeous and I wear this everyday.

Originally posted on influenster.com

bethanyc0056

Review1

Votes0

5 out of 5 stars.

bethanyc0056

6 years ago

Originally posted on influenster.com

mbeltran05

Review1

Votes0

5 out of 5 stars.

mbeltran05

6 years ago

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I love the color ! Md the think I like the most of these lipstick is that it’s not too sticky!

Originally posted on influenster.com

mbeltran05

Review1

Votes0

5 out of 5 stars.

mbeltran05

6 years ago

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I love the color ! Md the think I like the most of these lipstick is that its not too sticky!

Originally posted on influenster.com

undrtow77

Review1

Votes0

4 out of 5 stars.

undrtow77

6 years ago

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I really found this lipstick to be on par with more expensive brands. It didn’t dry my lips out. The cream finish was very natural looking. So much better than the dull matte finishes that are popular. I’m not a fan of that trend. Your lips should look dewy at least, which is a healthy, moisturized lip. The color pigment was good and long lasting. I would recommend it and would purchase it.

Originally posted on influenster.com

undrtow77

Review1

Votes0

4 out of 5 stars.

undrtow77

6 years ago

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I really found this lipstick to be on par with more expensive brands. It didnt dry my lips out. The cream finish was very natural looking. So much better than the dull matte finishes that are popular. Im not a fan of that trend. Your lips should look dewy at least, which is a healthy, moisturized lip. The color pigment was good and long lasting. I would recommend it and would purchase it.

Originally posted on influenster.com

keysyr

Review1

Votes0

4 out of 5 stars.

keysyr

6 years ago

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Very pigmented and long wearing, doesn’t stain, very easy to put on and take off, and also very easy to build. Blendable and has the ability to be subtly if you use a brush, nice smell and very rich texture when applied.

Originally posted on influenster.com

keysyr

Review1

Votes0

4 out of 5 stars.

keysyr

6 years ago

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Very pigmented and long wearing, doesnt stain, very easy to put on and take off, and also very easy to build. Blendable and has the ability to be subtly if you use a brush, nice smell and very rich texture when applied.

Originally posted on influenster.com

9 – 38 of 465 Reviews

Ratings & Reviews

Review this product

Select to rate the item with 1 star. This action will open submission form.

Select to rate the item with 2 stars. This action will open submission form.

Select to rate the item with 3 stars. This action will open submission form.

Select to rate the item with 4 stars. This action will open submission form.

Select to rate the item with 5 stars. This action will open submission form.

Be the first to review this product

No questions have been asked about this product.

Questions

No questions have been asked about this product.

Color Sensational® Lip Color

About

Benefits

How to apply

Ingredients

Review Highlights

Pros

Cons

Ratings & Reviews

Rating Snapshot

Overall Rating

Review this product

Customer Images and Videos

Filter Reviews

BMcK75

So disappointed

BMcK75

HoneyBearKelly

Great Lipstick

HoneyBearKelly

Montez

Disappointed

Montez

Lea20

The bestiario lipstick

Lea20

Divasivad

Truffle tease please!!!

Virology

Best lipstick I've ever bought!.

Virology

THT84

Nude Lust & Romantic Rose-Best Shades Ever!!

THT84

Melanie Kay

Plum Perfect is Perfect!

Melanie Kay

Ratings & Reviews

Rating Snapshot

Overall Rating

Review this product

Customer Images and Videos

Filter Reviews

MCon

Please don’t!!

MCon

Anonymous

Hooray!

Anonymous

Gracie13

Color looks pink!

Gracie13

Elle780

Wonderful but discontinued!

Elle780

Original LadyDi

Color has Changed!

Original LadyDi

Grams4

Great

Grams4

VJ crafter

Sugar Bronze

VJ crafter

Lipstick84

My Favorite Lipstick!!

Lipstick84

chelchel

BRING BACK RUM RICHE :(

chelchel

Cebo

Truffle Tease is my signature lipstick

Cebo

Tigerlaf

The best nude red ever

Tigerlaf

Coop321

910 Bare All

Coop321

Reshmavarun